An astute reader, and currently there aren’t many because I don’t publicize this site, suggested I should look at some older Reddit comments by a Redditor named Horror-Chocolate-224.
As I was late to the party, as Hayley pointed out to me in April 2021 after she booted me out of her Facebook group – I really didn’t know that the accusations against Matthew Good first surfaced online, on his Facebook Fan page – and that Kelly M who ran the page, took it down – and also on the Reddit forum that was closed in February 2021. Thanks for the tip tipster!
So I looked at what was left on Reddit. In particular the user account named Horror-Chocolate-224. Which appears now as a suspended account, so finding the posts was a deep dive into old posts.
These two Reddit comments were made the day before the Facebook group was made by Kim M on January 3, 2021.
So is Kim M, Horror-Chocolate-224 and possibly also Sherri from Twitter?
It seems to line up. From the description of their experiences and the fact they mention a miscarriage, the user account on Reddit by the name of Horror-Chocolate-224 matches Kim M.
I found it fishy that Hayley M was the only one that knew Kim M and how to contact her, and was able to get Kim’s user account on Facebook magically back in her power after it was supposedly hacked.
If you recall, Kim and Hayley stated they believed Raeleigh (Matt’s 2nd ex-wife) hacked that Facebook account named Kim M. Which is a crazy claim in and of itself.
It is all still strange to me – but if Kim M exists, and is a real individual and not an alias used by Hayley M or another woman out to take down Matthew Good… it still leaves some questions.
Specially reading these Reddit posts by Horror-Chocolate-224.
Key points, Horror-Chocolate-224 states:
- Matthew Good was married at the time (2010-2017)
- Raeleigh was pregnant at the time (so this was 2010-2012 time frame)
- Kim knew those two first points but claims she was convinced by Matt that she was his soul mate
- Kim knew he was married and his wife was pregnant but believed it was an open relationship
- Kim believed there was a future for her with Matthew Good
- Matt easily convinced her to do pornographic sexual things she wasn’t experienced with
- Kim regrets it now, and feels she was lied to and manipulated
- Kim says she was young and dumb and idolized him
- Kim says she has spent 8 years in therapy because of Matthew Good
- Kim is now married with two kids
Horror-Chocolate-224 is indeed Kim M those things line up, whoever Kim really is.
Even though it is still weird to me how everything went down in the Facebook Group, and it was fishy as hell how Hayley M handled it all. It is entirely possible that Hayley was duped by a woman with a vendetta against Matthew Good.
I have to say, these posts make me think Kim M is a person other than Hayley. I don’t know what he did to her that she needed therapy for – for 8 years, but I would assume being convinced you are your idol’s soul mate is a mind fuck. But 8 years?
In any case – the stories are out there now – here on this site – on Reddit – on another Tumblr site – and Matthew can’t hide from them.
I also have no idea what Horror-Chocolate-224 did to get her Reddit account suspended. If anyone knows more please email me. I have said all along, I want to hear what happened to each of these women. I am willing to share their stories – if they want more shared.
I have listened to Matthew Good‘s version of these stories, and I see what he thinks about all this – we very much disagree on a lot of things. These women didn’t use him. He used them.
I am very open to giving these women a platform here.
It is a difficult place to put myself – but I am here.
Updated September 23, 2023 – Uploaded February 3, 2022