This is a screenshot of a claim against the rockstar – from the comments on Matthew Good‘s IG on February 11th, 2021.
You can see some of these images also on the Tumblr site.
I do not know who runs that Tumblr.
Social Media Justice
Aside from this claim, on IG from username ging.er5718 (the IG account is now been deleted) – there is no other statements of this exact claim. No one in the Facebook group had this story posted when I was in the group in March/April 2021. Yet, a lot of people have seen this screenshot stating that she was 17 at the time, and he gave her an undisclosed STD. These comments were on Hayley‘s IG at the same time in 2021.
Note, I know Phaedra in this screenshot, and she and I have spoken directly. Her story has been removed from this site – not by her request – but by my decision.
Is ging.er5718 Kim?
After reflecting on the information regarding this ging.er5718 – I see the parallel accusations that were stated by Kim M the creator of the Victims of Matthew Good Facebook Group, and the Reddit user Horror-Chocolate and the Sherri on Twitter account.
In fact, there is one big clue I have intentionally skipped that makes me think I know exactly who is behind it all, but without verification, that of any of these people are actual individuals and not all the same person, I am not going to point to who it is.
They all tell the same story, with similar very personal details. So I have to wonder.
The information about ging.er5718 and the ‘school teacher’ description lines up with the Kim M story, for example.
In June and July 2021, I was confused by the multiple names used for ging.er5718 – which included the name Holly.
Several IG accounts were used including Taurus.Aries.Aries (which I am not sure is still the same user) and HollyTellsTheTruth – which is an account certainly about this MG MeToo Saga, and is still public at this time.
Trouble is, as much as an adult man having sex with a 17 year old is morally questionable, the Legal Age of Consent in Canada is 16.
Now you can argue the power imbalance of the situation, for sure, but 16 is legal age for consent.
Mental Health Care
In the end we all have to wonder, why would any woman lie about having sex with a rockstar?
I don’t doubt these young women had these experiences. There was only 1 woman out of all the ones we could verify the identity of that Matthew Good outright says is lying about ever having a sexual encounter with him. Since I can not verify who Kim M, or ging.er5718 or Horror-Chocolate are, and Matthew Good claims to not know who they are… it leaves me at an impasse.
All I can say is, I hope everyone gets the mental health care they need, the medications they need, and heal from whatever real or imagined hurt they endured.
Updated and Edited May 11, 2024 Original Uploaded January 16, 2022